Episode 115-The Murders of Ashley Pegram, Nicole Lovell, and Joseph Emmett Naulty

On April 4, 2015, 28-year-old Ashley Pegram, who was the mother of three small children, went missing after making plans to spend the evening with a man she’d met on a dating app, specifically on one called “Meet Me.” Pegram had been devastated after losing her boyfriend in a car accident a few months earlier, and was lonely and looking for someone to talk to online. She’d begun corresponding with a man named Edward Bonilla a few weeks...

Episode 114-The Murders of Bonnie Lou Irvine in Troutman and Andy Banks in Raleigh

In February of 2008, the roommate of 52-year-old Bonnie Lou Irvine, a Cornelius resident, reported the woman missing. Investigators with the Cornelius Police Department looked at her phone and e-mail records and noticed her last communication was with a man named Bernard Lamp, who was going by the name George Lamp. She’d responded to an ad he’d placed on Craigslist earlier in the month. Irvine had also sent Lamp a link to a different...

Episode 113-The Murder of Michael Hunter in Raleigh and the Ruth Buchanan Cold Case

On April 30, 1992 Joseph Mannino, a fourth-year medical student at the University of North Carolina living in northwest Raleigh, called 911 to report one of his roommates, 23-year-old Michael Hunter, was deceased in his bedroom. Mannino at first told police that he gave Hunter an injection of Benadryl and Vistaril—both antihistimines—for help with a migraine. But when the medical examiner took a close look at the whole picture, a puzzling...

Episode 112-Deaths by Suicide-Nathaniel and Irene Witherspoon, Leslie and William Cargile, John Barnett, and Mica Miller

This week marks National Suicide Prevention Week, which is an annual campaign designed to educate the general public about suicide prevention and the warning signs of suicide. This is a topic that resonates with so many of us. Chances are, you have a close friend or family member who has died by suicide or has had to receive counseling for their mental health. Nathaniel and Irene Witherspoon On January 4, 2024, residents in Franklin, North...

Episode 111-The Murder of Jeni Gray and the Abduction of Leigh Cooper in Boone

Located in the heart of the Blue Ridge Mountains, Appalachian State University is a four-year-college that also has a satellite campus in Hickory. The school was founded 125 years ago when Dr. B.B. Dougherty, his brother D.D. Dougherty, and D.D.’s wife, Lillie began dreaming of a way to help children in the state participate in educational opportunities in the heart of the mountains. App State began as Watauga Academy, progressed to the...

Episode 110-Four 1992 Deaths in Burke and Catawba Counties

A listener recently e-mailed me an article link about a cold case out of Catawba County. When I started reading about the unsolved murder of 13-year-old Isis Dee Dee Dawkins, I realized there was a connected story about a series of murders and suspicious deaths that took place during the summer of 1992, and it resulted in one man residing in a bus at a local junkyard being convicted of murder, and another local man being convicted of two...

Episode 109-Jim and Tammy Faye Bakker and the PTL Scandal

In the 1980s, an evangelical couple named Jim and Tammy Faye Bakker were literally everywhere, preaching the gospel through their own broadcasting network, living a lavish lifestyle, and building a grandiose Christian-theme park and accompanying on-site hotel in Ft. Mill, South Carolina. It didn’t matter what faith was, there was no way you didn’t know who Jim and Tammy Faye were. Today, we’ll take a look at how they Faye met and were led...

Episode 108-The Capture of Eric Rudolph, Part 2

Around 4 a.m. on May 31, 2003, 21-year-old rookie police officer Jeff Postell was making a second run patrolling the area behind the Valley Village shopping center in the town of Murphy, which at the time had under 2,000 residents, when he noticed a man ducking behind some milk crates at the Sav-A-Lot. Postell took a closer look because he thought he had interrupted a burglary in progress. When he noticed the man had a black object in his hand,...

Episode 107: Eric Rudolph, The Escape, Part 1

On July 27, 1996, a bomb exploded in Centennial Olympic Park in Atlanta during the Summer Olympic Games. Alice Hawthorne, a 44-year-old businesswoman and resident of Albany, Georgia, had decided at the last-minute to take her 14-year-old daughter Fallon to the celebration. She loved Atlanta and often traveled there to shop and attend events. She died as a result of injuries from multiple penetrating metal fragments from the bomb. Her daughter...

Episode 106: The Little Rascals Day Care Case

In 1980, a memoir titled “Michelle Remembers” chronicled a woman’s experience of childhood torture inflicted by a satanic cult. Canadian resident Michelle Smith recovered these memories, which allegedly occurred over a 14-month period when she was five years old, while working with her psychiatrist Larry Pazder. Michelle and Larry did an extensive media and book tour where they talked about the memories Michelle had uncovered after hours...